Skip to content
Open menu Close menu

Feed your appetite for cooking with Penguin’s expert authors

penguin logo

Alternatives to turkey this Christmas: game birds and chicken

by Malou Herkes

published on 6 November 2020

While most of us can get on board with a traditional Christmas turkey, with fewer guests to cater for and worries about food waste, 2020 might be the year many of us try something new and opt for a bird with smaller proportions. There are so many alternatives you can choose for a special Christmas centrepiece, particularly if you're catering for a smaller crowd. Guinea fowl, pheasant, duck and quail… even a good old roast chicken will do the job. Here we're sharing a selection of general guidance on cooking game birds and chicken, plus a selection of recipes to try.

Top tips for cooking game birds and chicken

1. Game birds, like pheasant and guinea fowl, are in season from September or October through to January or February, so Christmas is a good time to enjoy them. Whether you're cooking game or chicken, look out for well-reared, free-ranging birds. They are available in most supermarkets.

2. Some birds come with the giblets. Check inside the bird if they do, and remove them before cooking. Use giblets to make stock or gravy.

3. Don't let it dry out! Birds have a tendancy to dry out when overcooked – from quail to chicken, their varying sizes mean that cooking times will vary widely too. Be sure to follow instructions carefully. 

4. Basting during the cooking process will help keep the meat moist. Tilt the tin and use a spoon to scoop up some of the juices and drizzle it over. 

4. Leave to rest after cooking, covered with tin foil and a couple of tea towels so it stays warm.

Game bird and chicken recipes to try

alternatives to christmas turkey quail with caramelised onions the food of spain claudia roden

Quail with Caramelized Onions and Brandy from The Food of Spain by Claudia Roden

These tiny birds are full of flavour, which Claudia Roden pairs with slow-cooked onions, pan-braised together with brandy until the quail is beautifully tender and the onions deliciously sweet and caramelised. The key here is not to overcook quail – these birds require just 30 to 40 minutes and should still be slightly pink. Feeds two.

Order a copy of The Food of Spain here.

alternatives to christmas turkey guinea fowl with fennel river cafe cookbook

Guinea Fowl with Fennel from River Cafe Cook Book Easy by Rose Gray & Ruth Rogers

Guinea fowl has a mild gamey flavour, reminiscent of pheasant. This is a delicious way to serve it, cut into pieces and roasted all in one tray with fennel, pancetta and white wine. One bird feeds two people generously so keep that in mind if you want to scale up this recipe based on how many mouths you have to feed. This recipe feeds four.

Order a copy of River Cafe Cook Book Easy here.

alternatives to christmas turkey the best roast chicken ever harry eastwood the skinny french kitchen

The Best Roast Chicken Ever from The Skinny French Kitchen by Harry Eastwood

“This recipe is what I would call the golden Mercedes of roast chickens”, says Harry Eastwood, and we couldn't agree more. If you're going to roast a chicken for Christmas, try this recipe with a wild mushroom stuffing, flavoured with lemon, fresh herbs, lemongrass and garlic. Feeds four.

Order a copy of The Skinny French Kitchen here.

Mary Berry Tarragon Roast Chicken | Christmas chicken

Roast Chicken with Tarragon Butter and Melting Onions from Simple Comforts

Enriched with a tarragon butter and served alongside super soft onions, Mary's take on a roast chicken has all the special touches your Christmas meal deserves but with none of the stress.

Get your copy of Simple Comforts here.

alternatives to christmas turkey slow roast turkey with cherry sauce mary berry

Slow-Roast Duck with Port & Cherry Sauce from Classic by Mary Berry  

With a delicious, complex flavour, this fatty bird is more able to stand up to robust flavours, like the classic cherry or orange sauces it's often paired with. Try this cross between Chinese crispy duck and a standard roast duck with plenty of crisp skin and fall-apart moist and tender meat. Team it with a sweet-savoury port and cherry sauce, and duck-fat roast potatoes. Mary also suggests saving the duck giblets to make to make a flavoursome stock with the duck bones another day. Feeds four to six.

Order a copy of Classic by Mary Berry here.

Jamie Oliver Christmas Roast Goose

Roast Goose Slow-cooked with Christmas Spices from Jamie Oliver's Christmas Cookbook

Jamie's slow-cooked Christmas goose is brimming with festive flavours thanks to the blend of aromatic and warming spices used to coat the bird. Jamie also includes a brilliant get-ahead option for those of looking to prep early for the big day.

From the book


alternatives to christmas turkey 3 bird roast tim hayward food diy

3-Bird Roast from Food DIY: How to Make Your Own Everything by Tim Hayward

“There’s a long historical tradition of show-off feasting dishes made by inserting progressively smaller animals into each other”, says Tim Hayward whose slightly more modest recipe cooks three birds – duck, chicken and pheasant – one inside the other. With a layer of sausage and chestnut stuffing, and a layer of sage stuffing between each bird, this really is a centerpiece to remember. Feeds eight with plenty of leftovers. 

Order a copy of Food DIY here.


You might also like

View all


All of your favourite recipes from Jamie Oliver’s Together on Channel 4

Jamie Oliver is back with a brand-new cookbook and TV series to inspire your post-pandemic cooking. Together is a guide to reconnecting with your nearest and dearest over a good...


8 Cornish-inspired home cooking favourites from Rick Stein at Home

Rick Stein’s latest cookbook is packed with recipes celebrating Cornish ingredients and producers. Discover 8 of our favourites here.


10 recipes you’ll love in The Sweet Roasting Tin

75 laid-back, flavour-focused bakes await you in The Sweet Roasting Tin. Here are just 10 of our favourites, from an orange drizzle traybake to Black Forest cupcakes.


Subscribe to The Happy Foodie email newsletter

Get our latest recipes, features, book news and ebook deals straight to your inbox every week